The short answer: if your goal is net profit, a 24m catamaran wins. If your goal is lowest entry cost with some cost recovery, a monohull is cheaper but it will almost never generate a profit from charter.
The decisive difference is not length. It is cabin capacity per metre and charter market demand. For commercial charter, the catamaran’s ability to command roughly double the weekly rate of a comparable monohull outweighs its higher berthing costs.
The Numbers That Matter
Purchase Price: Monohull Is Cheaper Up Front
A new 24m monohull motor yacht starts around $5.5 million USD depending on specification, while a comparable 24m catamaran from a premium yard lists at €6.95 million to €10.78 million. The catamaran carries a significant acquisition premium—roughly 25–95% more depending on builder and finish.
Charter Revenue: Catamaran Earns Roughly Double
Across 1,325 real charter quotes, the median weekly rate for a catamaran was €7,120, versus €3,542 for a monohull—a difference of 101%. For larger 24m-class vessels, the gap widens further. A 24m catamaran can command €54,900–€90,000 per week in high-season Greece, while a monohull of similar length typically achieves €24,000–€55,000 for 8 guests.
The reason is structural: a 24m catamaran offers 5 equal cabins for 10 guests as standard, while a monohull of the same length maxes out at 4 cabins for 8 guests, often with smaller guest cabins. Charter clients pay per person, not per metre.
Operating Costs: Catamaran Pays More at the Dock
This is the catamaran’s Achilles heel. Marina berths are priced by beam, and a catamaran’s wide hull means fees are typically 1.5 to 2 times those of a monohull of the same length. Some Mediterranean marinas cannot accommodate catamarans at all.
Fuel tells a more nuanced story. A monohull’s single engine consumes roughly 5–6 litres per hourin typical charter use, while a catamaran’s twin engines can double that figure. However, sailing catamarans spend more time under sail and less under power, which can offset some of the fuel penalty in practice.
Crew costs are broadly similar for the same guest capacity, though a 10-guest catamaran requires crew certified for more passengers.
The Profit Calculation
For a 24m catamaran:
- Gross weekly charter: €54,900–€90,000
- Realistic charter weeks per year: 10–14 with dual-season positioning
- Gross annual revenue: €549,000–€1,260,000
- Operating costs: Crew, insurance, berthing (at the higher catamaran rate), maintenance, and management
- Net position: With strong booking and disciplined cost control, a positive cash flow is achievable
For a 24m monohull:
- Gross weekly charter: €24,000–€55,000
- Realistic charter weeks per year: 10–14
- Gross annual revenue: €240,000–€770,000
- Operating costs: Lower berthing, lower fuel, but same crew and maintenance baseline
- Net position: Cost recovery at best. The revenue ceiling is too low to outrun operating costs in most scenarios.
The broader industry data confirms this pattern. Charter income for crewed yachts typically covers 40–60% of running costs at best, and that is for vessels commanding premium rates. A monohull at the lower end of the rate spectrum will struggle to reach even that threshold. A well-positioned catamaran with 10-guest capacity operates from a fundamentally stronger revenue base.
The Hidden Factor: Market Demand Is Shifting Toward Catamarans
The charter market is not neutral between hull types. Catamarans offer “plenty of space, excellent structural stability, minimal heel, generally spacious outdoor areas and a quality of living that a monohull of comparable length cannot match”. For charter clients—families, groups, mixed-experience crews these are decisive advantages.
The practical consequence: catamarans charter more easily and at higher rates because they match what the market wants. A monohull may appeal to sailing purists, but purists are not the dominant charter demographic. Families and groups booking a week in Greece or the Caribbean want space, stability, and separate cabins. The catamaran delivers all three better than a monohull of the same length.
This demand dynamic also affects resale. A charter-spec catamaran with a proven booking history holds value better than a monohull in the same commercial role, because the buyer pool is larger.
Verdict: Catamaran for Profit, Monohull for Cost Control
| Factor | 24m Catamaran | 24m Monohull |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | Higher (€7–11M) | Lower ($5.5M+) |
| Weekly charter rate | €54,900–90,000 | €24,000–55,000 |
| Guest capacity | 10 (5 cabins) | 8 (4 cabins) |
| Berthing costs | 1.5–2× monohull | Baseline |
| Charter demand | Strong, growing | Moderate, niche |
| Profit potential | Positive cash flow possible | Cost recovery at best |
If you want to make money from charter, buy the catamaran. Accept the higher purchase price and berthing costs as the cost of accessing a revenue stream that the monohull simply cannot match. Choose a 5-cabin layout, ensure commercial registration from the outset, and position the vessel in a proven charter market with professional management.
If you want to own a yacht and recover some costs, the monohull is the cheaper entry. But do not expect it to pay for itself. It is a subsidised hobby, not a business.