The heart of the debate is a conflict of authority between the central Spanish government and the regional Balearic government. The national government approved a Royal Decree that allows private Spanish-flagged boats (List 7) to engage in rentals under certain conditions.
In contrast, the Balearic Islands passed its own decree in August 2025 regulating nautical charters in its waters, which prohibits this possibility. It mandates that all rental activity be conducted with boats registered on List 6.
This pits national regulations on merchant shipping and maritime navigation against the regional government’s power to regulate nautical activities. Both administrations have competence in this area, but it is delineated: the Balearic Government’s authority covers inland waters, while the central government’s covers open waters.
No “Irreparable Harm” Found
The TSJIB’s order states, as it did in another appeal against the decree, that the immediate application of the rule does not cause irreparable harm to private boat owners. The court noted that any potential damages would be economic in nature and, therefore, could be compensated if the main legal challenge ultimately succeeds.
Multiple Legal Challenges Pending
Four separate administrative appeals are currently being processed by the TSJIB:
1. One filed by the Ministry of Transport, focusing on the jurisdictional conflict.
2. One brought by the Association of Small Nautical Businesses of the Balearic Islands (APANIB).
3. One filed by the List 7 Boat Owners Association (the subject of this recent ruling).
4. One presented by a private company.
Beyond the List 7 rental ban, APANIB’s challenge questions other aspects of the regional decree, such as the requirement for charter operators to have a home port in the Balearics and the prohibition on selling individual tickets for spots on List 6 boats.
A fifth appeal, reportedly being considered by Spain’s National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC), could also be added. The CNMC’s preliminary opinion is that almost the entire decree violates freedom of enterprise and the European single market.
Implications for the 2026 Season
With this latest decision, the TSJIB has made it clear that, at least until a final ruling is issued—a process that could take several years given the backlog of cases against the administration in the Balearics—the regional decree remains fully in force. It will very likely govern all charter activity during the crucial 2026 high season.